Validation

See if you're on the right track.

Tree testing

What

A test to see how well people can navigate to the intended location of a given website structure. Conduct tree testing after card sorting to increase confidence in navigation content.

Why

To validate how well users understand the labels, categories, and organization of a proposed website structure, and learn where they may get lost while trying to complete a task.

Templates

Time required

30 minutes to 1 hour per test

How to do it

  1. Build the tree.
    • Use a tool like Optimal Workshop or a prototyping tool to create a site hierarchy, including all the categories and subcategories you want to test.
    • Provide options for each subcategory to prompt realistic behavior from participants who often evaluate link labels by comparing them with alternatives.
  2. Define the tasks.
    • Ask participants to find or do something within the site, focusing on key website goals and user tasks, as well as potential problem areas. Set at least one correct destination for every task.
    • Write tasks that reflect how people might naturally approach the site. Use plain language and avoid using tree labels in the tasks.
    • Limit the activity to 10 tasks to avoid low completion rates or participants getting too familiar with the tree.
  3. Run the test.
    • Send participants the link to the test or watch them do it in person.
    • If possible, ask follow up questions to get more context that can otherwise be hard to spot in the quantitative data.
  4. Analyze the results.
    • Optimal Workshop includes useful data for further interpretation, such as how many people completed each task successfully, how directly they found the destination, and how long it took them.

Example from Optimal Workshop

Additional resources

Considerations for use in government

This method works best with around 50 people, which has PRA implications. See the methods for Recruiting and Privacy for more tips on taking input from the public.